Saturday, December 5, 2009

Ranking Cloud Computing Vendors 2009

With the close of 2009 coming soon, I expect to see a number of “2009 - Cloud Computing in Review” type posts. Let me get a jump on everyone and release mine a few weeks early. Though I am a developer, my Cloud posts have all been analytical in nature and this one is no different. For this post I chose a single data source for stack ranking the Cloud Computing vendors – Google search results. Not terribly scientific, but an approach that produced interesting results.

Google as an Analysis Tool

I have created a number of editions of my Cloud Taxonomy over the last 18 months. The goal of that project was to help newcomers to the market understand what types of solutions are available and who the players are. My hope was that people would find it useful as a launching off point on their journey into the Cloud.

Tonight, on a whim, I decided to see what would happen if a person used Google instead as the start of their exploration of Cloud Computing. It was predictable that a high percentage of results are focused on “intro” or “definition” type pages. A lot of blog posts, tweets, and conference sessions have been devoted to defining what exactly is Cloud Computing. Let’s link to the NIST definition, and speak no more of that here.

What I found interesting was the relative ordering of vendors in the results list – it wasn’t what I expected at all. Given that Google Page Rank arguably orders results according to mind share, I expected certain vendors (e.g. Google, Cisco, GoGrid) to appear high above others. Looking at the results below, that didn’t happen.

To head off the flames, I recognize why this analysis isn’t scientific:

  • It is based off of a single data source – Google Page Rank
  • It is based off of a single search phrase – cloud computing
  • It assumes Page Rank == mind share

But its interesting to me nonetheless, so here we go.

Ranking the Cloud Vendors in 2009 on Mind Share

The table below shows the results. To collect this data, I did the following:

  • Cleared all browser cookies
  • Ensured I was logged out of Google (to avoid personalized results)
  • Navigated to the google.com search page
  • Typed “cloud computing” in the search box

And, here are the results. I first scrubbed anything that wasn’t a vendor or open source product. Then I noted the first time their domain (xxx.com) appeared, even if that listing was not their primary cloud page (sometimes the blog comes first). Google itself is the exception on this – hits on Google Groups/Blogger/etc did not count.

 

Result Page Rank Vendor URL

1

1 Rackspace http://www.rackspacecloud.com/
  2 Sun http://www.sun.com/solutions/cloudcomputing/index.jsp
  3 Salesforce http://www.salesforce.com/cloudcomputing/

2

4 Amazon http://aws.amazon.com/ec2/
  5 VMware http://www.vmware.com/solutions/cloud-computing/
  6 IBM http://www.ibm.com/ibm/cloud/
  7 Canonical/
Ubuntu
http://www.ubuntu.com/cloud

3

8 Dell http://content.dell.com/us/en/enterprise/cloud-computing.aspx

4

9 Oracle http://www.oracle.com/technology/tech/cloud/index.html
  10 RedHat http://www.redhat.com/solutions/cloud/
  11 Rightscale http://blog.rightscale.com/2008/05/26/define-cloud-computing/
  12 Microsoft http://www.microsoft.com/virtualization/en/us/cloud-computing.aspx

5

13 3tera http://www.3tera.com/Cloud-computing/

6

14 HP http://www.hpl.hp.com/research/cloud.html
  15 Yahoo http://labs.yahoo.com/Cloud_Computing
  16 Objectivity http://www.objectivity.com/cloud-computing/default.asp

8

17 Cisco http://blogs.cisco.com/tag/cloud+computing
  18 Enomaly http://www.enomaly.com/

9

19 CA http://www.ca.com/US/insights/topic.aspx?cid=8348

10

20 F5 http://www.f5.com/pdf/reports/cloud-computing-survey-results-2009.pdf

11

21 Appirio http://www.appirio.com/ecosystem/
  22 G.ho.st http://g.ho.st/
  23 Akamai http://www.akamai.com/cloud

12

24 Accenture http://www.accenture.com/Global/Services/Accenture_Technology_Labs/R_and_I/CloudComputing.htm

13

25 GoGrid http://www.gogrid.com/

16

26 Novell http://www.novell.com/cloud/

20

27 Citrix http://www.citrix.com/english/ps2/products/product.asp?contentID=1681633

21

28 Joyent http://www.joyent.com/
  29 Parallels http://www.parallels.com/spp/understandingclouds/

22

30 eyeos http://eyeos.org/
  31 Eucalyptus http://www.eucalyptus.com/

23

32 Appistry http://www.appistry.com/

24

33 Infosys http://wwwinfy.infyweb.akadns.net/cloud-computing/default.asp

25

34 Virtualmin http://www.virtualmin.com/
  35 Nimbus http://workspace.globus.org/

 

Congrats goes to Rackspace, as they topped the list.

These things surprised me:

  • Google? Where are you?
  • Amazon was not listed as the top result, and Rackspace was
  • Canonical/Ubuntu faired extremely well, given how new their enterprise cloud solution is
  • Cisco listed lower than expected at page 8, given how active they are in the blogging community

CloudFutures 2009 (Dec 7-8, San Jose)

In closing, this is a short plug for the CloudFutures conference coming up on Monday. I will be speaking on “The Real Cloud Players”. See you there!

4 comments:

Peter Laird said...

And this wasn't even original. Kevin Jackson did this last year (I know I must have looked at it then, but totally forgot).

So take a look at Kevin's work for comparison:

Kevin Jackson blog post

Balakrishna Narasimhan said...

Peter, thanks

hongaviles said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Biz Geek said...

Hi Peter, We recently launched cloudtaxonomy.com to foster further understanding and adoption of cloud based solutions. Please check it out. You can also find more information on my blog post http://blog.hsetty.com/2010/07/15/cloud-computing-taxonomy/